Guide · 6 minute read

Military sleep method vs the cognitive shuffle

Both are bedtime techniques for when your mind won't settle, but they take different approaches. One has you relax your muscles and then try to clear your mind; the other gives your mind something harmless to do. For a racing mind, that difference matters.

What the military sleep method is

The "military method" comes from a technique popularised in a 1981 book, Relax and Win by Lloyd Bud Winter, and widely credited with helping pilots fall asleep in difficult conditions. It has four steps, done lying down:

  1. Relax the muscles of your face — forehead, jaw, eyes, tongue.
  2. Drop your shoulders and let your arms go loose, one side at a time.
  3. Breathe out and relax your chest, then your legs, top to bottom.
  4. Clear your mind for ten seconds — then picture one calm, still scene (a canoe on a calm lake, lying in a black velvet hammock), or simply repeat "don't think" for ten seconds.

The popular claim is that with practice it can get you to sleep in around two minutes. The first three steps are essentially progressive muscle relaxation, a long-established relaxation exercise. The fourth step — clearing the mind — is where many people get stuck.

Where the cognitive shuffle differs

The cognitive shuffle targets that fourth step directly. "Clear your mind" is famously hard advice for an anxious mind — telling a racing brain to think about nothing usually just hands it more room to race. Instead of emptying the mind, the shuffle occupies it with a stream of random, unrelated, neutral images — a kettle, a meadow, a lantern — that give it nothing to build a story around. You don't have to clear anything; you just follow the words.

The military method starts with relaxing the muscles, then asks the mind to go quiet. The cognitive shuffle aims for a quiet mind by giving it something to do instead of asking it to stop.

Head to head

 Military methodCognitive shuffle
Main focusRelaxing the bodyOccupying the mind
The hard part"Clear your mind" (step 4)None — the words are supplied
Best forPhysical tension, restlessnessA racing, story-building mind
Learning curveTakes weeks of practice (per the book)Easy to start on the first night

The best move: combine them

They aren't rivals — they fit together neatly. Do the military method's muscle relaxation and slow breathing to settle your body, and when you reach the "clear your mind" step, run the cognitive shuffle instead of trying to think about nothing. Some people like the combination of a relaxed body and an occupied mind, though no study has tested it.

Let the shuffle handle step 4

Our free Sleep Shuffle tool supplies the random words and can speak them aloud, so once your body is relaxed you can keep your eyes closed and just listen. No app, no sign-up. See also how to fall asleep faster.

Sleep Shuffle is a relaxation aid, not medical treatment. Persistent sleep trouble is worth a conversation with a doctor — medical guidelines recommend CBT-I as the first treatment for chronic insomnia.