Guide · 6 minute read
How cognitive shuffling might help: the theory
Why might picturing a kettle, then a river, then a balloon help you fall asleep, when counting sheep often doesn't? The theory is about what your mind is allowed to do, not how boring the task is. It is a plausible idea with only a little direct evidence behind it so far.
This page is about the mechanism: why the idea makes sense. For a plain definition see what is cognitive shuffling?, and for what the studies found see does cognitive shuffling work?
What the cognitive shuffle is
The cognitive shuffle — more formally serial diverse imagining — is a sleep-onset technique developed by cognitive scientist Luc Beaudoin. The idea is simple: instead of letting your mind run its anxious late-night narrative, you deliberately feed it a sequence of random, unrelated, emotionally-neutral images, one after another. A teapot. A meadow. A duckling. A lantern. You picture each for a moment, then move on to the next, unconnected one.
Beaudoin's proposal was that the diversity and randomness are the key ingredients. The images must not connect into a story, because a story is the kind of thinking that tends to keep you awake.
Why a racing mind keeps you awake
When people can't sleep, it is often not that they aren't tired. In Beaudoin's view, the mind is engaged in coherent, goal-directed thinking — rehearsing a conversation, planning tomorrow, replaying something that went wrong. In his theory, this kind of ordered, sense-making thought signals to the brain that you are awake and need to stay alert. Beaudoin calls a mind in this state "insomnolent": its cognition looks nothing like the cognition of someone falling asleep.
A mind that is actually drifting off does something quite different. Its thoughts become loose, fragmentary, and disconnected — brief, drifting images that don't add up to anything. Sleep researchers describe this as typical of the move into sleep.
The idea is not to bore you to sleep. The cognitive shuffle imitates the disordered, drifting thinking that tends to come on its own as people fall asleep, on the theory that imitating it may help bring it on.
Why counting sheep may not help
Counting sheep is the opposite of a shuffle. It is ordered, sequential, and goal-directed: one sheep, two sheep, three. That structure is mild mental work — on this theory, the kind of coherent cognition that may keep the brain in its awake mode. A 2002 University of Oxford study by Allison Harvey and S. Payne, often reported as the "counting sheep" study, gave 41 people with insomnia one of three sets of instructions for a night: an engaging imagery task, general distraction, or nothing in particular. The imagery group fell asleep sooner and had fewer and less distressing pre-sleep thoughts than the group with no instructions. The cognitive shuffle takes that one step further: not one calm scene, but a constant supply of unrelated ones, so the mind has less of a thread to pull on. We compare the two head to head in cognitive shuffle vs counting sheep.
What sleep research says about pre-sleep thinking
A 2020 systematic review in Sleep Medicine Reviews (Lemyre, Belzile, Landry, Bastien and Beaudoin) gathered the research on what goes through people's minds before sleep. It describes the normal transition to sleep as marked by sensory imagery and a winding down of higher-level thinking, and reports that people with insomnia more often have planning and problem-solving thoughts at bedtime, which they also find more unpleasant. That is the pattern the shuffle tries to reverse. The same review found that techniques aimed at changing pre-sleep thinking have had mixed results, which is a useful reminder that a plausible theory is not the same as proof.
What the evidence does and doesn't say
Serial diverse imagining itself has been tested in one study so far, presented as a poster at the SLEEP 2016 conference: 154 students, with the shuffle doing about as well as structured problem-solving, and no untreated comparison group. The first author has a commercial interest in the mySleepButton app. In short, the theory fits what is known about sleep onset and the one direct result is promising but weak; the technique has not been through large, independent trials. Treat it as a free technique that may be worth trying, not as a cure. The details are in does cognitive shuffling work?
How to actually do it
You can do the shuffle entirely in your head: pick a random word, picture it for a few seconds, then pick another unrelated one. Most people find the hard part is generating words that are random enough — your tired mind keeps drifting back to whatever is bothering it. That is exactly what our free Sleep Shuffle tool is for: it supplies the neutral words for you, one every few seconds, and can even speak them aloud so you can keep your eyes closed. No app to install, no sign-up.
Things that pair well with a shuffle
The shuffle is meant to quiet the mind; these may help settle the body and the room. (Links marked sponsored are affiliate links — they may earn us a small commission at no cost to you.)
- A comfortable weighted blanket, if you like the feel of extra weight.
- A soft sleep mask so you can run the shuffle with your eyes closed.
- A white-noise machine to cover a noisy room.
Ready to try it? Open the Sleep Shuffle tool and start. Or read how to fall asleep faster when your mind won't stop.
Sources
- Beaudoin LP. The possibility of super-somnolent mentation: A new information-processing approach to sleep-onset acceleration and insomnia exemplified by serial diverse imagining. 2013. The original theory paper.
- Lemyre A, Belzile F, Landry M, Bastien CH, Beaudoin LP. Pre-sleep cognitive activity in adults: A systematic review. Sleep Medicine Reviews 2020;50:101253. A review of how thinking changes before sleep; background theory, not a trial of the shuffle.
- Harvey AG, Payne S. The management of unwanted pre-sleep thoughts in insomnia: distraction with imagery versus general distraction. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2002;40(3):267–277. 41 people with insomnia, one night; imagery distraction compared with general distraction and no instructions.
- Beaudoin LP, Digdon N, O'Neill K, Rachor G. Serial Diverse Imagining Task: A New Remedy for Excessive Cognitive Pre-sleep Arousal. Poster, SLEEP 2016, Denver. 154 university students; compared with structured problem-solving, no untreated control group. The first author has a commercial interest (CogSci Apps, maker of mySleepButton).
- Qaseem A, Kansagara D, Forciea MA, Cooke M, Denberg TD. Management of Chronic Insomnia Disorder in Adults: A Clinical Practice Guideline From the American College of Physicians. Annals of Internal Medicine 2016;165(2):125–133. Recommends CBT-I as the first treatment for chronic insomnia in adults.